April 2, 2026

What Actually Happens to Your Conversion Rate When You Migrate From Magento to Shopify Plus

What a named Magento migration case and Shopify’s checkout research can tell you, and how to set expectations for your own store.
7 min read
Flux Insights Static Hero
Adam Tregear
Founder @ Flux

A Magento to Shopify Plus migration can improve the buying experience, but the platform change alone does not establish a conversion forecast. Separate named case studies, vendor research and your own financial scenarios. Then build the plan around the friction your customers actually face.

The headline numbers


Before you migrate from Magento to Shopify Plus, establish the current conversion rate by device, channel and funnel stage. A 15 to 40 percent improvement can be modelled as a scenario, but it is not an established average or minimum for every migration.


Shopify’s Character.com case study reports 40 percent higher desktop conversion and 65 percent higher mobile conversion following Bluegg’s 2016 redesign and migration. Character.com moved to Shopify, then upgraded to Plus after the relaunch. The work also changed branding, navigation and product discovery, so this is a specific project result rather than a platform-only test.


Shopify’s commissioned checkout research reported an average 15 percent advantage against the competing platforms studied, and up to 50 percent higher conversion when using Shop Pay versus guest checkout. These are different comparisons. Neither establishes a 15 percent minimum lift for a Magento migration or a 50 percent increase in total-store revenue.

For a hypothetical brand doing $5 million in annual revenue, a 15 percent relative conversion lift could increase revenue at unchanged traffic and average order value. It is an assumption for the model, not a conservative result you can count on.


Where the lift comes from


The useful question is where customers struggle in the current store: finding products, choosing variants, understanding delivery or completing payment. Compare how each proposed implementation will address those problems. A maintained Magento store and a poorly implemented Shopify store can behave very differently from a headline comparison.


Checkout performance


Shopify provides a hosted checkout with supported customisation and payment options. Review the existing checkout’s errors, load behaviour, delivery rules and payment journeys before planning the replacement. Better conversion comes from removing relevant friction, not from assuming every Magento checkout has the same weaknesses.


Page speed


Measure real page loading, responsiveness and layout stability on representative devices. A custom headless Shopify storefront offers more implementation control, but it does not guarantee a faster experience. Images, scripts, caching and integrations still need to be designed and tested.


Mobile experience


Use your own mobile traffic share to set priorities. Test discovery, product information, variant selection, forms and payment on real phones. A migration can address a weak mobile experience, but both the old and new storefront need assessment rather than a platform-age assumption.


Shop Pay and accelerated checkout


Shop Pay can reduce repeat entry of payment and shipping details for eligible customers. Shopify’s study reported up to 50 percent higher conversion versus guest checkout when Shop Pay was used. That comparison is not a guarantee for every customer or store. See the published checkout research.


What a migration actually looks like


A well-executed Magento to Shopify Plus migration isn't a lift-and-shift. It's an opportunity to rethink the entire customer experience from the ground up. The brands that see the highest conversion gains treat migration as a strategic rebuild, not just a re-platform.


That means auditing the existing customer journey, identifying the friction points in the current Magento experience, and designing a Shopify Plus storefront that eliminates them. It means investing in performance: fast page loads, optimised images, clean code, and building a checkout flow that's been tested against real user behaviour.


The technical migration itself, moving product data, customer records, order history, and integrations, is the table stakes. The conversion gains come from the strategic and UX layer on top. Our Shopify migration service is built around this approach.


Setting realistic expectations


Model a 15% conversion scenario


A 15% relative improvement is a planning assumption to test, not a minimum result. Include a no-lift case and a downside case in the decision. Agree which changes are expected to affect the journey and how they will be measured.


Read the 40-65% example in context


The Character.com figures show what happened on one redesign and migration. They do not define an upside range every brand can expect. The current store, customer mix, implementation and measurement method all affect the result.


The settling period


Monitor orders, payment errors, checkout completion, stock and tracking from launch. A dip during the first two to four weeks is a reason to investigate, not something to dismiss as normal. A 60 to 90 day view can add context, but there is no universal settling period; traffic volume and seasonality affect how quickly a trend becomes clear.


The revenue impact


If you're currently converting at 2 percent on $5 million in annual revenue, a 15% conversion lift takes you to 2.3%, potentially adding $750,000 in annual revenue at the same traffic levels. A 40% lift takes you to 2.8%, potentially adding $2 million.


These calculations assume the same traffic, average order value and revenue definition. They describe gross revenue scenarios, not profit or a guaranteed return. Include migration costs, operating costs, returns and margin when deciding whether the investment works.


The bottom line


A migration is useful when it solves the business’s actual problems: an unreliable buying journey, difficult operations or requirements the current setup cannot sensibly meet. Keep the implementation and measurement plan attached to those needs.


There is no guaranteed conversion increase from changing platforms. Flux’s role is to plan the migration, improve the buying journey and check the commercial outcome. Start with the current problems and a measurable brief, then choose the work that addresses them.

/score

Does AI recommend your brand?

We ask ChatGPT and Perplexity 10 real buying questions for your category and score you against your biggest competitor. Live, in about 2 minutes.

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Free. Enter your store's website, e.g. yourstore.com

Flux is a Shopify Plus Agency for Advanced Engineering & AEO

TLDR Summary
  • A migration can improve conversion, but there is no standard lift.
  • Character.com’s 40% desktop and 65% mobile figures describe Bluegg’s 2016 redesign and Shopify migration, followed by a Plus upgrade.
  • Shopify’s checkout study and Shop Pay comparison are separate from total-store migration results.
  • Build financial scenarios from your own traffic, conversion, average order value and margin.
  • Investigate launch problems immediately; do not assume a dip is a normal settling period.